Claw vs Club: Which Hammer Is Right for the Job?

July 22, 2025

Claw vs Club: Which Hammer Is Right for the Job?

When it comes to must-have hand tools, the hammer is about as iconic as it gets. But not all hammers serve the same purpose — especially when you compare a claw hammer to a club hammer. In this post, we’re putting two heavy hitters from Town Tools to the test: the Bahco 428 Curved Claw Hammer and the Roughneck Gorilla Club Hammer.

Let’s break down their differences, what they’re built for, and which one belongs in your tool bag.

🔨 What is a Claw Hammer?

Tool: Bahco 428 Curved Fibreglass Claw Hammer 454g / 16oz

This claw hammer is a classic — lightweight, balanced, and built for precision.

Key Specs:

Weight: 454g (16oz)
Handle: Durable fibreglass with anti-slip grip
Head: Drop-forged steel
Design: Curved claw for easier nail pulling

Best For:
✔️ Framing and finishing
✔️ Driving/pulling nails
✔️ Light demolition
✔️ General carpentry and joinery

Why It Stands Out:
The Bahco 428 gives you controlled power and comfort. Its fibreglass handle reduces shock and makes it easier to use for long periods — ideal for day-to-day trade use or DIY jobs.

🔨 What is a Club Hammer?

Tool: Roughneck Gorilla Club Hammer 1.4kg / 3lb

This is the heavy-hitter you need for tougher jobs. The Roughneck Gorilla is compact, but its short, thick head packs serious punch.

Key Specs:

Weight: 1.4kg (3lb)
Handle: Solid fibreglass with soft-grip
Head: Drop-forged steel with black painted finish
Design: Short-handled sledge style

Best For:
✔️ Demolition work
✔️ Driving chisels or stakes
✔️ Breaking concrete or brick
✔️ Landscaping and masonry

Why It Stands Out:
The Roughneck Club Hammer is made for force. It gives you high-impact results in a compact form — especially useful when swinging room is tight or when you're working outdoors.

🆚 Claw vs Club – Which Should You Choose?

Feature	Bahco Claw Hammer	Roughneck Club Hammer
Weight	454g (light)	1.4kg (heavy)
Best For	Framing, nails, carpentry	Demolition, masonry, stakes
Handle Type	Fibreglass with grip	Fibreglass with soft grip
Main Benefit	Precision & control	Raw striking power
Ease of Use	Great for everyday use	Heavier, more specialised

✅ Conclusion:

Need a versatile hammer for day-to-day site work?
Go for the Bahco Claw Hammer – it's light, precise, and ideal for all-round use.

Working with brick, concrete or landscaping materials?
Reach for the Roughneck Club Hammer – it brings serious impact when the job calls for it.

Either way, you're covered with pro-grade gear from Town Tools.
👉 Browse our full range of hammers and hand tools here

Filed in: 16oz hammer, 3lb hammer, bahco hammer, best hand tools, best value hammer, blacksmith hammer, breaker hammer, carpentry gear, carpentry hammer, claw hammer, claw vs club hammer, club hammer, compact sledge, curved claw hammer, demolition hammer, DIY hammers, fibreglass hammer, fibreglass handle hammer, framing hammer, general purpose hammer, gorilla hammer, hammer review UK, hammer specs, hammer strength test, hammer weight guide, hand tools UK, hardware tools, heavy duty hammer, heavy hammers, jobsite tools, joinery tools, landscaping hammer, lightweight hammers, masonry tools, nail puller hammer, power tools alternative, roofing hammer, roughneck hammer, sealey hand tools, sledge alternative, soft grip hammer, steel hammer, toolbox essentials, town tools, trade quality tools, tradesperson tools, uk tool shop, workshop tools

Previous article 5 Must-Have Hand Tools Every Tradesperson Swears By

Thor Round Solid Copper Mallet 38mm 955g Thor - Town Tools

£44.99 - £44.99

£44.99

£44.99 - £44.99

£44.99

Thor Round Solid Copper Mallet 38mm 955g

Thor

In stock

This Thor Round Solid Copper Mallet has the following specification:Round Head Diameter: 38mm (1.1/2in)Approximate Weight: 955gApproximate Length: ...

View full details

£44.99 - £44.99

£44.99

£44.99 - £44.99

£44.99

Thor 317 Copper Hammer Size 4L (50mm) 2830g Thor - Town Tools

£73.99 - £73.99

£73.99

£73.99 - £73.99

£73.99

Thor 317 Copper Hammer Size 4L (50mm) 2830g

Thor

In stock

1 x Thor 317 Copper Hammer Size 4L (50mm) 2830g.

£73.99 - £73.99

£73.99

£73.99 - £73.99

£73.99

Thor 710N Thorex Nylon Hammer 32mm 385g Thor - Town Tools

£18.99 - £18.99

£18.99

£18.99 - £18.99

£18.99

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull Tuff Bar 600mm (24in)

£17.99 - £17.99

£17.99

£17.99 - £17.99

£17.99

Faithfull Tuff Bar 900mm (36in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£22.99 - £22.99

£22.99

£22.99 - £22.99

£22.99

Faithfull Tuff Bar 900mm (36in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull Tuff Bar 900mm (36in)

£22.99 - £22.99

£22.99

£22.99 - £22.99

£22.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Boiler Scaling Hammer 454g (16oz) Faithfull - Town Tools

£20.99 - £20.99

£20.99

£20.99 - £20.99

£20.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Boiler Scaling Hammer 454g (16oz)

Faithfull

In stock

The Faithfull FSC Hickory Boiler Scaling Hammer is specially designed for removing deposits and scale from metalwork. The head is ground to a chise...

View full details

£20.99 - £20.99

£20.99

£20.99 - £20.99

£20.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 400mm (16in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 400mm (16in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 400mm (16in)

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Claw Hammer Handle 350mm (14in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Claw Hammer Handle 350mm (14in)

Faithfull

In stock

Replacement claw hammer handle in straight grained hickory with a waxed finish. Faithfull replacement wooden handles are made with FSC® 100% Certif...

View full details

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Faithfull FSC Black Rubber Mallet 24oz Faithfull - Town Tools

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Black Rubber Mallet 24oz

Faithfull

In stock

This Faithfull Black Rubber Mallet has the following specifications: Colour: Black.Face Size: 60 x 100mm.Weight: 24oz.Handle Size: 340mm.

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 425mm (17in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 425mm (17in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 425mm (17in)

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Geologists Pick Handle 330mm (13in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£10.99 - £10.99

£10.99

£10.99 - £10.99

£10.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Geologists Pick Handle 330mm (13in)

Faithfull

In stock

Replacement geologists pick handle in straight grained hickory with a waxed finish. Faithfull replacement wooden handles are made with FSC® 100% Ce...

View full details

£10.99 - £10.99

£10.99

£10.99 - £10.99

£10.99

Faithfull Joiners Hammer FSC Hickory 454g (16 oz) Faithfull - Town Tools

£14.99 - £14.99

£14.99

£14.99 - £14.99

£14.99

Faithfull Joiners Hammer FSC Hickory 454g (16 oz)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull Joiners Hammer FSC Hickory 454g (16 oz).

£14.99 - £14.99

£14.99

£14.99 - £14.99

£14.99

Faithfull FSC White Rubber Mallet 24oz Faithfull - Town Tools

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Faithfull FSC White Rubber Mallet 24oz

Faithfull

In stock

This Faithfull White Rubber Mallet has the following specifications:Colour: White.Face Size: 60 x 100mm.Weight: 24oz.Handle Size: 340mm.

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Faithfull Sledge Hammer Fibreglass Handle 4.54kg (10 lb) Faithfull - Town Tools

£37.99 - £37.99

£37.99

£37.99 - £37.99

£37.99

Faithfull Sledge Hammer Fibreglass Handle 4.54kg (10 lb)

Faithfull

In stock

Weight: 4530g (10 lb)

£37.99 - £37.99

£37.99

£37.99 - £37.99

£37.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Joiners Hammer Handle 325mm (13in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£9.99 - £9.99

£9.99

£9.99 - £9.99

£9.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Joiners Hammer Handle 325mm (13in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull FSC Hickory Joiners Hammer Handle 325mm (13in)

£9.99 - £9.99

£9.99

£9.99 - £9.99

£9.99

Faithfull Black Fibreglass Mallet 16oz Faithfull - Town Tools

£6.99 - £6.99

£6.99

£6.99 - £6.99

£6.99

Faithfull Black Fibreglass Mallet 16oz

Faithfull

In stock

This Faithfull Black Fibreglass Mallet has the following specifications:Colour: Black.Face Size: 55 x 100mm.Weight: 16oz.Handle Size: 260mm.

£6.99 - £6.99

£6.99

£6.99 - £6.99

£6.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Pin Hammer Handle 279mm (11in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Pin Hammer Handle 279mm (11in)

Faithfull

In stock

Replacement pin hammer handle in straight grained hickory with a waxed finish. Faithfull replacement wooden handles are made with FSC® 100% Certifi...

View full details

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Sledge Hammer Handle 610mm (24in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Sledge Hammer Handle 610mm (24in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull FSC Hickory Sledge Hammer Handle 610mm (24in).

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

£11.99 - £11.99

£11.99

Faithfull Sledge Hammer Fibreglass Handle 3.18kg (7 lb) Faithfull - Town Tools

£30.99 - £30.99

£30.99

£30.99 - £30.99

£30.99

Faithfull Sledge Hammer Fibreglass Handle 3.18kg (7 lb)

Faithfull

In stock

Weight: 3170g (7 lb)

£30.99 - £30.99

£30.99

£30.99 - £30.99

£30.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 275mm (11in) Faithfull - Town Tools

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 275mm (11in)

Faithfull

In stock

1 x Faithfull FSC Hickory Ball Pein Hammer Handle 275mm (11in)

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

£7.99 - £7.99

£7.99

Faithfull FSC Black Rubber Mallet 28oz Faithfull - Town Tools

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Faithfull FSC Black Rubber Mallet 28oz

Faithfull

In stock

This Faithfull Black Rubber Mallet has the following specifications:Colour: Black.Face Size: 70 x120mm.Weight: 28oz.Handle Size: 340mm.

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

£8.99 - £8.99

£8.99

Shop More